Beyond Position One: Decoding the Real AI Overviews SERP Impact

 

Introduction

The digital marketing world is buzzing about Google’s latest evolution: AI Overviews. These AI-generated summaries, designed to provide instant answers, are reshaping the search engine results page (SERP) as we know it. For years, the goal was simple: rank number one. But as AI carves out its own space on the page, the landscape is shifting, demanding a new level of strategic SEO adaptation and forcing us to ask a critical question: what is the true AI Overviews SERP impact?

Background

AI Overviews are Google’s attempt to directly answer a user’s query with a synthesized summary compiled from multiple web sources. The common assumption has been that these overviews would exclusively own the top of the SERP, effectively creating a new \”position zero.\” However, recent data challenges this notion.
A groundbreaking analysis of 10 million SERPs by Ahrefs, with data from Xibeijia Guan and analysis by Patrick Stox, reveals a fascinating wrinkle. While most AI Overviews do appear first, a notable 8.64% show up outside of the first position, sometimes ranking as low as sixth. This tells us that Google doesn’t treat its own AI answers as infallible.

The Trend and Its Implications

This trend of variable AI overview positions isn’t uniform, with countries like Japan and Spain seeing a higher incidence of lower-ranked overviews. This suggests Google is actively experimenting, possibly using the quality and confidence of the generated answer as a ranking factor for the overview itself.
Think of it like this: an AI Overview is like a new hire presenting a report. When the report is clear, confident, and well-sourced, it’s featured at the top of the meeting agenda (Position 1). But if the report is hesitant or incomplete, it gets pushed down, allowing more established experts (the traditional organic results) to take the lead.
This has profound implications for search engine optimization. It means the #1 organic ranking is far from obsolete. If you can provide a better, more comprehensive answer than the AI, you can still win the top spot and the lion’s share of the clicks. This transforms the threat of AI into an opportunity for quality.

A Strategic Forecast

Looking ahead, we can predict that the SERP will become even more dynamic. The AI Overviews SERP impact will not be a monolithic change but a fluid one. We anticipate Google will continue refining its algorithms, meaning the position of an AI Overview could change based on the query’s nuance and the quality of the underlying source content.
For businesses and marketers, this is a call to action, not a reason to panic. The game is no longer just about ranking; it’s about becoming the undeniable source of truth that Google’s AI must cite and feature prominently.

Your Call to Action

The path forward requires a renewed focus on strategic, high-quality content. It’s time to adapt your SEO strategy:
* Double Down on E-E-A-T: Produce expert-driven, authoritative content that is difficult for an AI to replicate or summarize poorly.
* Monitor Your Keywords: Keep a close eye on your most valuable SERPs. Is an AI Overview present? Where is it ranking? This is now a critical piece of your digital marketing insights.
* Become a Primary Source: Structure your content with clear answers, unique data, and expert insights to position your site as an essential source for AI Overviews.
To dive deeper into the data and see how these trends are unfolding, we highly recommend reading the full analysis on the Ahrefs blog. The age of AI in search is here, but the advantage still belongs to those who provide real, undeniable value.
*
Citations:
– Stox, Patrick. \”AI Overviews positions: 8.64% show outside of position 1.\” Ahrefs Blog, https://ahrefs.com/blog/ai-overviews-positions/.